flag
back Back
'Full circle' - Referees chief congratulates VAR on making amends for reckless Man United error

Manchester United goalkeeper Andre Onana was guilty of conceding a late penalty in Saturday's 1-1 draw with Burnley at Old Trafford.

Andre Onana clatters into Burnley forward Zeki Amdouni.
Andre Onana conceded a late penalty against Burnley.

Howard Webb - the head of Premier League refereeing - has said Andre Onana should have been booked for recklessness after conceding a penalty in Manchester United's 1-1 draw with Burnley at Old Trafford on Saturday.

The United shot-stopper was guilty of conceding a spot-kick in the closing stages after clattering into Burnley forward Zeki Amdouni. Onana attempted to come and claim a loose ball in the air, misjudged it, and ended up smashing into Amdouni's head.

On-field referee John Brooks did not point to the penalty spot, instead signalling for a Clarets corner. However, VAR official Peter Bankes told Brooks to delay the restart, recommending him to go over to the pitchside monitor and review the decision.

After reviewing the decision, Brooks decided to point to the spot, handing Burnley an opportunity to cancel out Antony's opener and claw themselves level. Amdouni stepped up, sent Onana the wrong way and sealed a vital point for the visitors in their quest to beat the drop.

The incident was almost identical to the one where Onana clattered Wolves striker Sasa Kalajdzic on the opening weekend of the season back in August. The United shot-stopper won none of the ball, but somehow escaped conceding a penalty.

Comparing the weekend's incident with that one, Webb said: "Like we talked about earlier, when we make an error, we look at why and what we can do better. We share all of that learning with our group, having discussed it with them.

"And we acknowledge that, that situation in week number one at Old Trafford should have led to a VAR intervention and didn't. This is very similar - Onana coming out and not making contact with the ball, making heavy contact with his opponent, not seen by the referee on the field. He sees [Aaron] Wan-Bissaka head the ball away but doesn't see the contact on Amdouni and the VAR sees that pretty quickly.

"It's a clear error not to award the penalty kick, and therefore recommends that the referee looks at it at the screen for himself and sees that heavy contact. And it is a penalty kick and there's no support for non-award of a penalty.

"Hence the reason it's a clear error. And we called it correctly and it's pretty efficient as well. So another good use of VAR. And thankfully this one was called correctly."

Giving his verdict on the scenario alongside former United striker Michael Owen, Webb was asked by the former England man if Onana should have been sent-off. Admitting a red card would have been a stretch too far, he believes he should have been cautioned by Brookes.

"I think there's a recklessness to it," Webb added. "On the day he wasn't cautioned. I think that that would have been the right outcome to show a yellow card as well, for a reckless action.

"I don't think it's serious foul play. I don't think there's excessive force or brutality in that challenge, but there's an element of recklessness. And that would normally lead to a yellow card."

You may like

Guardiola says ‘goodbye to Man City’ as Barcelona ‘do everything possible’ to hire him

football365.com a day ago

Kevin De Bruyne's jaw-dropping wife steals the show during Man City's title celebrations

dailystar.co.uk a day ago

David Beckham worries he's 'going to get killed' after making honest Jurgen Klopp comment

express.co.uk 9 hours ago

"We all want to win but we are competing against monsters"

besoccer.com a day ago

Getafe game suspended after fans aim chants at Mason Greenwood as manager releases furious statem

sportbible.com 2 days ago

Jose Mourinho given surprise job offer with ex-Man Utd boss facing unlikely reunion

mirror.co.uk 2 days ago

Man City player 'kicked out' of team's title-winning celebrations after 'trying to fight fellow p

sportbible.com a day ago

Jose Mourinho gets new job offer in role former Man Utd boss has never had before

express.co.uk a day ago