flag
back Back
Fans fume ‘where is the consistency?’ as Ederson gets away with same challenge Man Utd’s Onana gave away penalty for

Man City keeper stirs debate in 2-0 win after flattening Forest defender Bola

EDERSON sparked a penalty controversy as fans compared an unpunished challenge from the Manchester City keeper to a costly blunder from Man United's Andre Onana.

Viewers were divided after one supporter blasted "inconsistent" decisions in two big Premier League matches in the space of 24 hours.

Ederson collided with Forest's Willy Boly in a major talking point
Ederson collided with Forest's Willy Boly in a major talking point

Onana clattered into Zeki Amdouni with both arms on Saturday - conceding a spot-kick from which the same Burnley midfielder tucked a late equaliser.

Then with the scores still level in City's 2-0 win at Nottingham Forest, Ederson and home defender Willy Boly tumbled after their aerial collision.

One fan posted: "Onana legit conceded a penalty for this yesterday. Where's the CONSISTENCY in this league?" while another insisted it was the "same foul".

A few others claimed it was a "scam" - suggesting United have been unfairly targeted this season.

A batch of Arsenal supporters were also upset by the decision.

That's partly because City went on to move second, a point behind the Gunners but with a game in hand.

A Josko Gvardiol header and a poacher's finish from fit-again sub Erling Haaland clinched victory, which left Forest just a point above the drop zone.

Most read in Football

One angry fan reacted: "Checking Badge…. Confirmed. It's Man City, not United. No penalty."

But many viewers seemed staggered by comparisons between the two incidents.

And some reckoned that, if there was an offender, it was the Forest star.

Erik ten Hag hits back with message to fans and 'forgetful' Man Utd icons after being booed for substitutions v Burnley

One fan wrote: "This is nowhere near the same… Boly completely throws himself at Ederson. Onana punched the Burnley player."

A Red Devils' supporter argued: "Boly fouls Ederson here. We all hate City , but let’s get facts correct."

And a third observer said of the two clashes: "Not even remotely the same thing bro."

This weekend's dispute follows two big spot-kick debates involving handball claims the previous weekend when City and United triumphed in their FA Cup semi-finals.

Chelsea were infuriated when VAR cleared Jack Grealish of handball, despite his flailing arm making contact with a Cole Palmer free-kick as Pep Guardiola's men won 1-0.

Then the next day pundits were split after United's Aaron Wan-Bissaka WAS penalised for handball, enabling Coventry to complete a 3-3 comeback from 3-0 down in the FA Cup semi-final before the Red Devils went through 4-2 on penalties.

Man Utd's Aaron Wan-Bissaka was penalised for this handball
Man Utd's Aaron Wan-Bissaka was penalised for this handball

You may like

Surprise Kylian Mbappe to Arsenal transfer confirmation emerges amid £60m wage issue

football.london 3 hours ago

Arsenal fans say the same thing after Son Heung-min miss as hilarious Pep Guardiola reaction spot

sportbible.com an hour ago

Kylian Mbappe will join ARSENAL and not Real Madrid, claims IShowSpeed as he slams Fabrizio Roman

thesun.co.uk 12 hours ago

Liverpool do Arsenal a favour despite brilliant Aston Villa comeback in 3-3 thriller

express.co.uk a day ago

Man City in huge title blow as Ederson cries for five minutes after suffering head injury in brut

thesun.co.uk an hour ago

Man City FFP cheating means Arsenal are Premier League champions

football365.com a day ago

‘Look at his eyes’: Pundit says Pep Guardiola did something he’s never seen before on the touchli

manchestercity.news an hour ago

Ashley Cole in line for first managerial role as clubs chase ex-Arsenal and Chelsea star

mirror.co.uk a day ago

Arsenal fans are all in agreement about Radu Dragusin’s display for Tottenham v Manchester City

thespurs.news an hour ago

Real Madrid player ratings vs Alaves: Dortmund beware - Jude Bellingham and Vinicius Jr aren't sl

goal.com an hour ago