Goalkeeper & Defence

Ederson (7/10):

Blameless for the goal, then mostly a passenger but stayed aware. Saved Luka Modric's spot-kick then nailed his own.

Kyle Walker (5/10):

A rusty return after a month out. Lost Rodryro, and his footing, for the opening goal after playing Madrid's forwards onside. Redeemed himself by shutting down a Vinicius attack in extra-time.

Ruben Dias (6/10):

Dazzled by Vinicius for the opener then steadied himself and blocked Madrid's exit routes in the second half.

Manuel Akanji (7/10):

Took the hybrid role baton from John Stones and ran with it, playing a big part in City's turnaround.

Josko Gvardiol (7/10):

Given a rough time by Federico Valverde at the start but came out fighting, making valuable blocks and interceptions until the 120th minute.

Midfield

Rodri (5/10):

Not at his best but played the game with his head, up to pulling back Brahim Diaz to stop him running clean through.

Kevin De Bruyne (6/10):

Looked like a man on a mission, relentlessly chasing the ball and trying to make something happen. After many bungled attempts he found the equaliser and then should have wrapped the game up in normal time.

Bernardo Silva (5/10):

Helped drag Madrid from side to side and his tireless running contained Vinicius Junior after the break. But his penalty was awful, straight down the middle and easily trapped by Lunin.

Attack

Phil Foden (6/10):

No firecracker goals this time and quiet by his usual standards but played his part in the second half dominance. Bungled a big chance in extra-time, then banged in his penalty.

Erling Haaland (5/10):

An improvement on his dire display in Madrid, hitting the bar with a header, but it was yet another big game he failed to score in.

Jack Grealish (6/10):

Had a fascinating duel with Dani Carvajal and was responsible for some of City's best attacks. A surprise substitution for Jeremy Doku but Pep knows best.

Subs & Manager

Jeremy Doku (7/10):

His pace and trickery gave Madrid an extra weapon to deal with and he sparked the equaliser, albeit with helping hand from Rudiger. Continued to cause them havoc in extra-time.

Julian Alvarez (5/10):

Replaced Haaland for extra-time to offer fresh legs and more movement but couldn't have much of an impact. Took his penalty perfectly.

John Stones (N/A):

Introduced in the 112th minute.

Mateo Kovacic (N/A):

Replaced De Bruyne in the 112th minute and lost his nerve in the shootout.

Pep Guardiola (6/10):

Got a proper reaction after half-time and bringing on Jeremy Doku gave his side an edge. But taking off Haaland when a shootout was likely will go down as an error of judgement.